The Neurobiology of Morals

January 17th, 2008

Steven Pinker was kind enough to publish a lovely introduction to the biological basis of morals, from discussion of evolutionary and philosophical foundations, to the analogy of the visual illusion in forming quirks in moral reasoning such as the following…

On your morning walk, you see a trolley car hurtling down the track, the conductor slumped over the controls. In the path of the trolley are five men working on the track, oblivious to the danger. You are standing at a fork in the track and can pull a lever that will divert the trolley onto a spur, saving the five men. Unfortunately, the trolley would then run over a single worker who is laboring on the spur. Is it permissible to throw the switch, killing one man to save five? Almost everyone says “yes.”

Consider now a different scene. You are on a bridge overlooking the tracks and have spotted the runaway trolley bearing down on the five workers. Now the only way to stop the trolley is to throw a heavy object in its path. And the only heavy object within reach is a fat man standing next to you. Should you throw the man off the bridge? Both dilemmas present you with the option of sacrificing one life to save five, and so, by the utilitarian standard of what would result in the greatest good for the greatest number, the two dilemmas are morally equivalent. But most people don’t see it that way: though they would pull the switch in the first dilemma, they would not heave the fat man in the second.

Link (NY Times)

Musical experience improves brainstem pitch following for language

January 12th, 2008

Wong, Skoe, Russo, Dees & Kraus (2007) Nature Neuroscience. 10 (4): 420-422.
Abstract: Music and speech are very cognitively demanding auditory phenomena generally attributed to cortical rather than subcortical circuitry. We examined brainstem encoding of linguistic pitch and found that musicians show more robust and faithful encoding compared with nonmusicians. These results not only implicate a common subcortical manifestation for two presumed cortical functions, but also a possible reciprocity of corticofugal speech and music tuning, providing neurophysiological explanations for musicians’ higher language-learning ability.

I’ve been meaning to go over this paper for some time, after being first mentioned a few months ago. It’s a fascinating study for two reasons. Firstly, it shows that experience-related (music, in this case) plasticity in the auditory pathway is not necessarily specific to one class of stimuli. The musical experience gained by subjects in this study seems to have helped with their ability to perceive linguistic patterns. The more traditional view is that there is some sort of strict dichotomy between music and language, the most facile example being that music is right-brained and language is left-brained. The second reason why I find this study fascinating is that this effect was observed in the brainstem. That is, before the cortex — which is usually depicted as the highly flexible and dynamic organ responsible for learning.

The authors took a sample of musically-trained individuals and compared their Frequency Following Response (FFR) with that of controls when listening to pitch-differentiated Mandarin words. Mandarin is known as a tone-language, in that much of the information is conveyed in the pitch of the word. In this case, a /mi/ sound was used, which has three different meanings depending on whether a rising, dipping or level inflection is used.

The FFR, as you might imagine, reflects tracking of pitch in scalp-recorded potential, and is thought to originate from the Inferior Colliculus (a structure just before the thalamus, which serves as a relay station for most sensory information). Best demonstrated by the representative figures below:

Ah, representative figures. The grey line shows the change in frequency (pitch) of the dipping /mi/ sound, and the yellow line shows it being tracked by the FFR. Note that the musician was able to track the pitch of this (previously unfamiliar) Mandarin word, while his or her counterpart in the control group could not. The authors interpreted this as evidence that the musician brain more faithfully encodes pitch information. Representatives cases aside, Wong et al also demonstrated pitch tracking differences between groups, with the effect strongest in those who started musical training early and stuck with it for a long time. It’s worth noting that even though this response is observed prior to the cortex, it is probably still driving plasticity via top-down feedback.

The major implication of this research, hinted at in the abstract above, is that musical training can drive language development - something well worth considering when developing K-12 curriculum.

Living the dream

December 22nd, 2007

Randall Munroe, proprietor of the charming webcomic xkcd, selected a rather unusual piece of lounge room furniture recently.

Optic Flow and the IBRO World Congress of Neuroscience

December 9th, 2007

The 2007 International Congress of Neuroscience ran in Melbourne from the 12th to the 17th of July. It’s not every day that one of the world’s biggest neuro conferences is in your hometown! Yes, I only just got around to blogging it. Please forgive me if the details are a little fuzzy.

The first session I attended was a plenary by Prof. Mandyam Srinivasan, a neuroethologist who studies bee behaviour at ANU (and, more recently, at UQ). This was probably the best neuroscience lecture I had ever seen - I’d love to be able to give such charming presentations. Mandyam has amassed a substantial collection of high impact papers detailing the bee vision system, in particular, the concept of optic flow.

Because bee eyes are so close together, they don’t get much in the way of 3D information via parallax. However, they are able to infer distances by measuring how much of the world rushes by; the closer you are, the faster the surface appears to move. Think driving down a highway - trees by the road rush by, whilst hills in the distance remain static. This can be demonstrated by training bees to fly down a tunnel, with the striped walls attached to a sort of conveyor belt. By moving the walls at different speeds, you can mess with the bee’s flight down the narrow tunnel. Humans use these cues too, by the way.

He also talked about some work on decoding bee dances, extending research that earned Karl von Frisch the Nobel Prize in 1973. Srinivasan’s group has demonstrated that distances to food sources communicated by these dances are measured with respect to optic flow, such that the bees can be tricked into giving misleading dances if they travel down the tunnel with striped conveyor belt walls to get their food reward. It also seems that when bees traverse over low contrast terrain, such as calm open water, they perceive distances as being smaller (link to PLoS Biology paper).

This is shown in the photo above, in the path heading south west . The feeding station (white dots) was gradually moved away from the hive, over land, then water, then land again on the island.

Distance is communicated to other bees in the hive using a “waggle dance“. Briefly, the bee does a little loop, and then a zig-zag type motion (”waggle”), the duration of which is directly proportional to the distance to the food source (a sucrose solution). As shown above, the distance communicated is smaller when over low-contrast terrain, like open water. This is reflected in significance testing of curve fit slopes for each segment. This suggests that the bees are using optic flow to measure distance, as opposed to, say, energy consumption. An interesting tale lies in how one might conduct an experiment to test this alternate hypothesis, but I’ll save that one for another day.

The final talk of the visual motion processing symposium, given by Prof. Dario Floreano, director of the Laboratory of Intelligent Systems at École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne in Zurich, also covered optic flow. It was quite different to the other talks, and certainly appealed to my inner engineer. Dario uses optic flow to get tiny autonomous flying robots (below) to navigate and avoid obstacles.

The planes fly in a room dubbed the holodeck, where different images, of varying contrast, can be projected onto the walls. Despite being sold as having heady military applications, Dario pointed out that this was mostly just for fun. My kind of project! That tiny 10 gram plane includes two cameras, two gyroscopes, an accelerometer, an anemometer, a bluetooth radio, and a microcontroller!

Finally, I invented the following award.

Award for Best Item of Exhibitor Swag
Not being a clinical conference, there weren’t any picnic baskets or trips to Tahiti on offer. There was, however, this…

It’s a reflective slap band thingy you put around your trouser leg to stop it getting caught in your bike chain! Get it? Neuroscientists are dorks who ride bikes with their pants tucked into their socks! I love it!

Downtime

October 4th, 2007

My apologies for letting deadpopstar.com regress three years - some clumsy oaf has been messing with the server defaults. Similarly, I apologize for the lack of updates. I never really believed people read this blog, but since going on hiatus, visits have halved. So, I guess they do.

If you’d like to see what I’ve been working on, you might like to visit Wilson Hall at the University of Melbourne on October 24th, where my work will be unleashed upon the unsuspecting public. It forms part of the “Endeavour” exhibition, and runs from 11:30am til 4pm.

DrinkLarge

August 25th, 2007

Check out this long overdue parody of the snooty Melbourne Uni ‘DreamLarge’ campaign, courtesy of ProshWeek2007.

The latest in car anti-theft technology

August 5th, 2007

Cool, eh? From Tesla Downunder.

My apologies for the lack of more substantial updates. It’s been a busy final semester, and I’ve been spending my free time on another web project, to be released shortly.

Neurobiological Correlates of Melbourne-Sydney Rivalry

July 11th, 2007

The Neurocritic reports on a paper in Australasian Psychiatry which finally reveals why Sydneysiders live in overpriced real estate, are woefully inept at sport, and are unable to land an NHMRC grant. (Link, Follow up)

My favourite comic character of 2007 is…

July 1st, 2007

…Bad Decision Dinosaur!

BDD appears at Cat and Girl (1, 2, 3).

Tickling a lab rat

June 24th, 2007

Not, that’s not some sort of euphamism - there is evidence to suggest that you can induce rats to laugh through tickling, and that they find this to be a pleasant experience.

I wonder if this could be used as a reward in behavioural studies? The usual approach is to get them all sugared-up on cocoa pops…

TierneyLab: What Happens When You Tickle a Lab Rat?